Home » Blog » Why Acid Etching Is No Longer Recommended as a Concrete Prep Method

Why Acid Etching Is No Longer Recommended as a Concrete Prep Method

The longevity of a coating partly depends on how well it adheres to the surface of the concrete. The best adhesion requires a clean floor, free of laitance and contaminants.

Laitance is a weak, milky accumulation of fine particles of cement dust, lime and sand fines on the surface of fresh concrete, usually caused by an excess of water bleeding to the surface.

Acid etching is the process of applying hydrochloric/muriatic or buffered phosphoric acid to a slab, then rinsing it off with water. For many years, it was a standard method of concrete preparation used by nearly all industrial, commercial and institutional floor coating installers, depending on the floor size and system to be installed.

Today, safer, eco-friendlier and more consistent concrete prep methods are the norm. Most coating manufacturers no longer recommend acid etching for a multitude of reasons.

Acid Etching Results Are Inconsistent

Acid etching removes laitance, but cannot remove curing compounds or many of the contaminants found in industrial settings, such as oily deposits and water-insoluble materials, any of which can interfere with the adhesion of a coating.

Improper surface preparation can result in poor bond and lack of coating adhesion.

Improper surface preparation can result in poor bond and lack of coating adhesion.

 

Additionally, because every slab is different, the results can be unpredictable and unreliable, even when the process is done by experienced professionals. The surface can end up uneven, over-etched, or under-etched.

Acid Etching Creates Only a Minimal Profile

Concrete Surface Profile, or CSP, as defined by the International Concrete Repair Institute (ICRI), is a standardized measure for the ‘roughness’ of a given concrete surface. This can range from CSP-1 (smoothest) to CSP-9 (roughest). The thicker the coating system, the higher the required CSP number.

Acid etching tends to produce a CSP-1 to CSP-2 profile, which is suitable for only for very thin systems, such as the low solids, solvent-based coatings of the past. Today’s low emissions and solvent free industrial, commercial and institutional resinous flooring systems tend to be much thicker, requiring CSP-3 to CSP-9 for best bond and performance; this essentially renders acid etching obsolete. Contractors look to mechanical concrete preparation, such as diamond grinding, shot-blasting and scabbling to create the higher CSPs needed.

The right concrete prep is the foundation for flooring success, like this cheerful FloroThane MC System in a custom yellow, skillfully installed by Florock UK.

The right concrete prep is the foundation for flooring success, like this cheerful FloroThane MC System in a custom yellow, skillfully installed by Florock UK.

 

Acid Etching Can Damage the Slab

The chemical reaction that occurs when an acid solution is applied to concrete is difficult to accurately predict and control. When applied to the surface, over-etching can easily occur, often making the surface more porous. When the acid is finally rinsed from the surface, the water can more easily enter the porous slab, resulting in potential corrosion of metal rebar and eventual weakening of the entire slab structure.

Acid Etching Can Be Hazardous to Humans and the Environment

It is not surprising that any physical contact with certain acids can cause chemical burns or other injuries. Lesser known, however, is that even inhaling the fumes from concentrated muriatic acid is extremely dangerous, because it can turn the moisture in the windpipe and lungs into a virtual acid solution. Even with safety equipment, the risks remain significant.

Clean rinse water is introduced to the floor after the etching reaction is completed. This neutralizes the acid solution to a certain degree, provided the rinsing is done correctly. Nevertheless, many local and federal agencies have imposed restrictions on washing the solution (“neutralized” or not) down the floor drain, due to the risk posed to waterways and the environment as a whole.

Acid Etching Can Add Time and Cost to a Project

Regulations for warehousing and shipping high concentration acids involves multiple safety measures and extensive paperwork, thus increasing cost on etching products.

contact-florock-cta

Finally, acid etching introduces water to the concrete, which is best avoided with many of today’s zero V.O.C. and ultra-high solids coatings. Once the substrate is saturated, the contractor must then decide to either wait any number of days for the slab to completely dry or choose a moisture tolerant primer that may add cost to the project. Prepping via mechanical means, rather than acid etching, can be much faster and far more economical.

Our Network of Technical Experts

At Florock, our mission is to give you the best possible solution to meet your facility needs. Our network of experts understands the ins and outs of concrete preparation and its effects on the life of your resinous flooring system, and will work with you to help ensure you receive optimal flooring value.